GIF vs MP4 vs WebP: Which Format Should You Use?
By GIF Toolkit · 6 min read ·
Short looping animations can be shared in three common formats. They differ a lot in size, quality and where they work, so the right choice depends on where the animation is going to be viewed.
The short answer
Use GIF when it must play and loop everywhere with no setup, such as in a chat message, a forum post, an email or a platform that only accepts images. Use MP4 when quality and file size matter and the place you are publishing supports video. Use animated WebP on websites where you control the page and want a small, image-like file with good color.
GIF
GIF is the lowest common denominator. Almost every browser, chat app, forum and email client displays it, and it autoplays and loops without a player. That reach is its only real strength.
Its weaknesses are significant. It is limited to 256 colors per frame, which causes banding and dithering noise in photographic footage. It has no sound. It also compresses poorly, so files are large for their length and resolution.
MP4
MP4 with H.264 video is vastly more efficient. The same clip is commonly a fraction of the size of the GIF while looking sharper, with full color and optional sound. On a web page, a muted MP4 set to autoplay and loop behaves much like a GIF but loads far faster.
The drawback is that MP4 is a video, not an image. Many places that happily accept a GIF will not treat an MP4 as an inline animation. Some platforms show a player with controls instead of looping silently, and email clients generally do not play it at all.
Animated WebP
Animated WebP sits between the two. It behaves like an image, supports millions of colors and transparency, and is usually much smaller than a GIF. Current versions of the major browsers display it.
Its limitation is support outside the browser. Some messaging apps, older software and many upload forms still reject it, and editing tools handle it less consistently than GIF. It is a good fit for your own website, and a risky choice when you do not control the viewer.
Side-by-side comparison
These are general tendencies, not guarantees, since results depend on the clip and the encoder settings.
- File size: MP4 smallest, WebP close behind, GIF largest.
- Color: MP4 and WebP support millions of colors, GIF is limited to 256 per frame.
- Transparency: GIF has single-color transparency, WebP has full alpha, standard MP4 has none.
- Sound: only MP4 supports audio.
- Autoplay and loop anywhere: GIF is the most reliable, WebP is good in browsers, MP4 depends on the platform.
- Editing and tool support: GIF is the most widely supported, MP4 is very well supported, WebP is patchy.
How to decide
Ask where the animation will be seen. If you are posting into an app that only takes images, make a GIF and keep it short and small. If it is going on your own page, use MP4 or WebP and enjoy the smaller download. If you are unsure, make the GIF for compatibility and keep the original video as the high-quality version.
To go from a GIF to the smaller format, the GIF to MP4 tool converts an existing GIF into a video you can embed or upload.